Bleached Creek Highlights ADEM Shortfalls, Say Critics

Posted by .

Buck Creek in Saginaw, Alabama, as seen from Ozley Road

Dan Carsen, WBHM

Buck Creek in Saginaw, Alabama, as seen from Ozley Road

Alabama has some of the most ecologically rich waters in the world. But the agency tasked with monitoring them gets less funding per capita than that of any other state, according to a study by the Environment Council of States. Some complain the Alabama Department of Environmental Management (ADEM) is not doing its job. One recent example that conservationists cite is Buck Creek in unincorporated Saginaw, near Alabaster, Alabama.

David Butler of Cahaba Riverkeeper, an environmental watchdog group, is there taking water samples and measurements. There’s a chemical smell, and the creek bed is almost white.

Cahaba Riverkeeper David Butler takes readings from Buck Creek.
Cahaba Riverkeeper’s David Butler takes readings from Buck Creek.
Dan Carsen, WBHM

“I would challenge you to find anything living in the water here,” says Butler.

He’s been testing the creek, and so has ADEM. The pH levels have come back similar to those of household cleaning products, and there was no visible life downstream of the pollution’s source: a nearby Carmeuse Lime and Stone processing plant. It’s unclear when the contamination began, but Butler filed a complaint with ADEM 14 months ago.

“We discovered it last year in June,” he says. “There’s still no resolution to it. Even with this ongoing damage that you see here, the state found it appropriate to go ahead and issue a fine without really looking at the impact.”

Carmeuse is a billion-dollar multinational. ADEM fined the company $32,000.

For its part, Carmeuse has paid the fine, and a spokesman says in a written statement, “after becoming aware that uncontrolled drainage was occurring to Buck Creek, Carmeuse immediately began an investigation to identify the source of that drainage. Initially, an area of surface erosion from a waste lime storage area was identified as the likely source. Further investigations conducted by Carmeuse also identified several areas impacted by water infiltration along the embankment of a reclaimed quarry pit … [We] began a hydrogeologic investigation to understand the cause of the water infiltration.”

Carmeuse Lime and Stone's Longview facility as seen from Highway 31 in Saginaw. The plant borders Buck Creek.
Carmeuse Lime and Stone’s Longview facility as seen from Highway 31 in Saginaw. The plant borders Buck Creek.
Dan Carsen,WBHM

Butler thinks the fine ADEM imposed is too low.

“When you have a company that has the resources to fight the state, there’s just not going to be significant penalties,” he says. “It discourages the companies that do do the right thing from spending the extra money to make sure that they’re in compliance with the law. Because if you break the law, you get a slap on the wrist.”

An ADEM spokeswoman declined to discuss Buck Creek. She did point me to a recent report outlining the agency’s funding challenges. It warns of potential cuts to basic functions like monitoring, testing, and inspection.

Some tools of the water-inspection trade
Some tools of the water-inspection trade
Dan Carsen, WBHM

“What do we expect?” asks Pat Byington, who was on the state commission that oversees the agency. “ADEM used to get funding at a level of about five to six million dollars a year. In the last couple years, it’s virtually been zero.”

Now the agency relies heavily on permit fees paid by businesses and on federal EPA dollars. But EPA money is unpredictable. ADEM has increased its permit fees to make up for some of the losses. Byington, though, worries that sets up a system where the companies being regulated financially support the regulators:

“They’ve been raising more and more monies on the people they’re supposed to be watching – they’re the ones paying the freight.”

After decades of working on environmental issues across the state, Byington is not optimistic about ADEM’s funding outlook. He says Buck Creek is just one recent example of why. But he’s not questioning motives at Alabama’s regulatory agency.

“The people at ADEM, I know, care about the environment,” he says. But, “One thing we all know is that ADEM is terribly underfunded. And it’s just like not having cops on the street.”

Environmental advocates want voters to demand more state funding for ADEM, so staff can do the work, and so there’s more accountability to taxpayers.

In the meantime, Buck Creek is still polluted, even as it flows through a popular wading spot on its way to the Cahaba River.

David Butler discovered this apparently new contamination in late July of this year. He said the contamination was similar to Buck Creek, into which this ditch drains.
David Butler discovered this apparently new contamination just recently — in late July, 2017. It’s in a ditch next to Ozley Road in Saginaw. He said the contamination was similar to that of Buck Creek, into which this ditch drains.
Dan Carsen, WBHM