Dr. Minda Berbeco On Alabama’s New Science Standards
Alabama’s State Board of Education on Thursday approved new K-12 science standards that will go into effect next school year. Science teachers across Alabama say the new standards are better than the current decade-old ones. We wanted a national perspective too, so WBHM’s Dan Carsen caught up with Dr. Minda Berbeco, Programs and Policy Director for the National Center for Science Education. He asks if she’s surprised there hasn’t been much controversy about standards dealing with politically charged topics like evolution and climate change. Above is the four-minute on-air version. Below are key excerpts and the nine-minute web-exclusive version.
Alabama’s Potential New Standards And Science Itself
“… we’re really pleased that there hasn’t been a strong pushback against the science standards, because it’s just science. And sometimes science is ugly, and sometimes science is uncomfortable, but we can’t really change the science. What we can change is the political response. It’s really important that the science is being taught and it looks like these standards are really trying to connect with what science shows, which is nice to see. You know, I always feel like standards could be even better and they could incorporate more concepts and more ideas, but this is a great starting point.”
NCSE
National Center for Science Education programs and policy director Minda Berbeco.
The Challenges of Teaching Climate Change
“First and foremost, because the science is very new, they might not have actually learned about climate change themselves when they were in school, so there’s a big professional development piece. Second, though — and I think we can’t overlook this … because it is politically controversial, teachers are really facing challenges not just from students but from parents getting upset that they’re addressing climate change, and possibly also from administrators. We’ve certainly worked with and talked to plenty of teachers who are really concerned about pushback just for teaching the science.”
Alabama’s Potential New Science Standards Embracing Evolution
“We’re really pleased to see that! Some really significant changes in their portrayal of evolution and certainly around the term ‘theory’ as well. So I think we’re cautiously optimistic.”
Education Reporting’s “Dirty Little Secret”: Standards Don’t Always Trickle Down…
“I think that’s a really good point. You can put anything you want into standards, but when the classroom door closes, the teacher’s in charge. And it’s really up to them to bring in the good scientific material. And this is why professional development is such an integral and central part of if you’re going to bring in new standards. You need to make sure teachers have the training and the materials that they need in order to teach to them.”
Below is the web-only extended version of the conversation.
Q&A: A former New Orleans police chief says it’s time the U.S. changes its marijuana policy
Ronal Serpas is one of 32 law enforcement leaders who signed a letter sent to President Biden in support of moving marijuana to a Schedule III drug.
How food stamps could play a key role in fixing Jackson’s broken water system
JXN Water's affordability plan aims to raise much-needed revenue while offering discounts to customers in need, but it is currently tied up in court.
Alabama mine cited for federal safety violations since home explosion led to grandfather’s death, grandson’s injuries
Following a home explosion that killed one and critically injured another, residents want to know more about the mine under their community. So far, their questions have largely gone unanswered.
Crawfish prices are finally dropping, but farmers and fishers are still struggling
Last year’s devastating drought in Louisiana killed off large crops of crawfish, leading to a tough season for farmers, fishers and seafood lovers.
Lawmakers consider medical cannabis revamp
It’s been three years since Alabama lawmakers passed legislation establishing a system to govern medical cannabis in the state, yet not one prescription for the drug has been filled. The rollout has been delayed by lawsuits and conflict over the licensing process.
Man arrested in connection with device that exploded outside Alabama attorney general’s office
Kyle Benjamin Douglas Calvert, 26, of Irondale, Alabama, was arrested Wednesday on charges of malicious use of an explosive and possession of an unregistered destructive device, the U.S. attorney’s office said.
